Beyond the Scope

How Medical Science Made Endoscopy Safe During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Discover how healthcare professionals redesigned protocols and validated safety measures to continue essential endoscopic procedures during a global health crisis.

The Invisible Enemy in the Endoscopy Suite

When the COVID-19 pandemic swept across the globe in early 2020, healthcare facilities faced an unprecedented challenge: how to continue providing essential medical services while protecting both patients and staff from a highly contagious virus. Nowhere was this dilemma more acute than in endoscopy units, where doctors perform procedures using flexible tubes with cameras to examine the digestive and respiratory systems.

Aerosol-Generating Procedures

Many endoscopic examinations are considered aerosol-generating, potentially releasing virus-containing droplets into the air 1 6 .

Complex Instrument Design

Endoscopes have multiple channels and crevices that could theoretically harbor viral particles between patients 2 .

This is the story of how medical professionals rapidly redesigned entire service delivery systems, validated new safety protocols, and ensured that life-saving diagnostic procedures could continue even during the height of a global health emergency.

Reimagining the Endoscopy Service: More Than Just Cleaning Scopes

Patient Screening and Triage

Facing this new threat, endoscopy units couldn't operate as usual. The University Hospital of Pisa in Italy, designated as a COVID-19 referral center, implemented a multidisciplinary task force to completely redesign their workflow 2 6 .

Pre-procedure Testing

Patients underwent SARS-CoV-2 testing via nasopharyngeal swabs or other samples shortly before their procedures 2 .

Symptom Assessment

Screening for COVID-19 symptoms like fever, cough, fatigue, loss of taste or smell, and gastrointestinal issues 6 .

Selective Postponement

Rescheduling non-urgent elective procedures while maintaining emergency and essential cancer-related endoscopies 6 .

PPE and Physical Distancing

Healthcare workers in endoscopy units faced significant exposure risks, particularly during procedures on the upper digestive tract and airways.

PPE Protocol for High-Risk Procedures:
High-filter respirators Waterproof gowns Double gloves Eye protection Hair nets Shoe covers

Based on protocols from 6

Additional Safety Measures:
  • Physical distancing in waiting areas
  • Reduced staff during procedures
  • Dedicated procedure rooms for suspected or confirmed COVID-19 patients 2

The Science of Scope Reprocessing: Eliminating an Invisible Threat

What is Endoscope Reprocessing?

Endoscope reprocessing refers to the meticulous multi-step cleaning and disinfection process that all reusable endoscopes must undergo between patients. Even before COVID-19, reprocessing was critically important because endoscopes come into contact with mucous membranes and internal body fluids 2 .

Standard Reprocessing Steps:
Bedside pre-cleaning 100%
Leak testing 100%
Manual cleaning 100%
High-level disinfection 100%
Drying and storage 100%

Enhancing Protocols for SARS-CoV-2

While standard reprocessing protocols are effective against many pathogens, the pandemic prompted hospitals to verify and often enhance their approaches specifically for SARS-CoV-2.

Key Improvements
  • Using disinfectants with proven virucidal activity against coronaviruses
  • Extending contact times with disinfectants
  • Implementing more frequent environmental cleaning 1 6
  • Enhanced training and competency assessments for staff 3

The Validation Experiment: Proving the Protocols Worked

Methodology: Putting Reprocessing to the Test

Despite theoretical confidence in these enhanced protocols, the healthcare community demanded scientific proof. Researchers at the University Hospital of Pisa designed and executed a crucial experiment to verify the efficacy of their endoscope reprocessing against SARS-CoV-2 1 2 6 .

Experimental Approach:
  1. Sample Collection: Testing 16 endoscopes after use on COVID-19 patients but before reprocessing, and again after complete reprocessing 1 2
  2. Sampling Technique: Using liquid samples flushed through channels and swab samples from external surfaces 1 6
  3. Viral Detection: Analysis with highly sensitive RT-PCR method 1 6
  4. Environmental Monitoring: Sampling surfaces in procedure rooms and washer-disinfectors 1

Results and Analysis: The Proof Was in the Testing

The experimental results provided much-needed reassurance to the endoscopic community:

Sample Type Number Tested Positive for SARS-CoV-2 Viral Elimination Efficacy
Bronchoscopes 5 0 100%
Gastroscopes 6 0 100%
Colonoscopes 5 0 100%
Washer-Disinfectors 2 0 100%
Environmental Surfaces Multiple 0 100%

Most significantly, all samples collected from endoscopes after reprocessing tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 1 6 .

Comparison of Reprocessing Protocols
Reprocessing Step Standard Protocol Enhanced COVID-19 Protocol
Pre-cleaning solution Standard enzymatic detergent Enhanced virucidal detergent
Contact time with disinfectant Manufacturer's minimum Extended contact time
Environmental cleaning Standard frequency Enhanced frequency
Staff training Periodic Enhanced and more frequent
Quality verification Bacterial culture Viral PCR testing added

"The improvement in endoscope reprocessing implemented during the COVID-19 emergency was effective in ensuring the absence of SARS-CoV-2, thus reducing the risk of infections after an endoscopy on COVID-19 patients" 1 .

The Scientist's Toolkit: Key Materials in the Validation Study

The successful verification of endoscope reprocessing relied on several specialized reagents and equipment.

Item Function Specific Example
Viral transport media Preserve viral integrity during sampling eSwab 490 CE COPAN swabs 1
Sample concentration devices Increase detection sensitivity Macrosep Advance Centrifugal Devices 1 6
SARS-CoV-2 detection Identify viral RNA cobas® SARS-CoV-2 Test (Roche) 1 6
Washer-disinfector equipment Automated high-level disinfection Soluscope series 4 6
High-level disinfectant Destroy viruses and other pathogens Peracetic acid at 900 ppm 6
Cleaning solutions Remove organic material Neo Proteozim Plus 500 6
Virology

Advanced detection methods to identify even trace amounts of viral RNA

Engineering

Specialized equipment for automated cleaning and disinfection

Clinical Medicine

Application of validated protocols in real healthcare settings

Conclusion: A Legacy of Safety Beyond the Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic forced rapid innovation in endoscopy safety protocols, leading to validated approaches that protected both patients and healthcare workers during a vulnerable time. The comprehensive research demonstrated that with proper protocols, endoscopic procedures could be performed safely even on infectious patients.

Key Achievements
  • Scientific validation of enhanced reprocessing protocols
  • Implementation of rigorous screening procedures
  • Heightened attention to airborne transmission risks
  • Establishment of a new standard of safety in endoscopic care
Lasting Impact

The lessons learned extend far beyond the current pandemic. These evidence-based protocols continue to protect patients not just from SARS-CoV-2, but from countless other pathogens that could otherwise find their way from one patient to another through medical equipment.

The scientific verification done during this crisis thus represents a lasting contribution to medical safety—proving that even in darkness, we can find ways to shine a light forward.

The information in this article is based on published scientific research, particularly studies conducted at the University Hospital of Pisa that were published in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 1 6 .

References